Areios Pagos: Lack of a building permit is not sufficient for a neighbor to be awarded compensation

Unauthorized Construction on a Neighbor’s Rooftop: When Is Compensation Guaranteed?
A significant legal development has altered the landscape for property owners whose views, natural light, or ventilation are compromised by unauthorized structures on adjacent buildings. In its ruling 573/2026, the A2 Civil Section of the Court of Cassation (Areios Pagos) clarifies that the mere fact that a structure lacks a building permit is not, in itself, sufficient to compel its owner to pay compensation to a neighbor.
Background of the Case: The dispute originated in Lamia, where, on a plot containing two adjacent buildings, the owner of one property constructed an unauthorized room—measuring nearly 30 square meters and standing 3.5 meters high—on the rooftop (terrace), positioned directly next to a neighbor’s penthouse. Despite the imposition of urban planning fines, a criminal conviction, and the subsequent "regularization" (legalization) of the unauthorized structure, the owner of the penthouse—and, subsequently, his heir—sought compensation for the resulting decline in the commercial value of their property. The Court of Appeal initially awarded compensation of €15,704, concluding that the value of the penthouse had decreased by 20%.
The ruling of the Court of Cassation (Areios Pagos): The Supreme Court overturned the Court of Appeal’s decision, distinguishing between a "formal" and a "substantive" zoning/building violation:
Formal violation (No compensation for neighbors): If a structure is built without a permit but does not exceed the area’s legal limits regarding building density, site coverage, or height, the owner faces only administrative penalties (fines) and criminal sanctions. Neighbors are not entitled to civil compensation.
Substantive violation (Giving rise to a claim for compensation): For compensation to be awarded, it must be proven—with specific figures—what the permitted building regulations were, that the unauthorized structure exceeded these limits, and that this specific excess caused the harm (e.g., loss of light, ventilation, or view).
What does this mean for property owners and engineers? The threshold of proof required in legal claims has been raised significantly. When a property owner seeks compensation for the devaluation of their property caused by an adjacent unauthorized structure, a simple estimate of the reduction in market value is insufficient. A detailed technical report from an engineer is required, comparing the applicable zoning and building regulations with the actual dimensions of the structure, while substantiating a direct causal link to the loss of view or sunlight.
Tip for buyers & sellers: During the technical due diligence of a property—especially penthouses or apartments with an unobstructed view—examining the regulatory compliance of neighboring buildings is just as critical as inspecting the property itself, as the legal protection of a view now requires rigorous documentation based on zoning and building regulations.



Comments